Nominations Clarifications - 1/?
Sep. 22nd, 2025 10:35 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Hello Everyone!
We are well on our way through nominations cleanups, and we've discovered some tags that could use clarification. Please read the following and respond if you see your tag (Anon is on for comments). You are also welcome to respond if it is not your tag, but you think you have input that may help the mods in figuring it out - please clarify that you are not the nominator in that case.
To the mods’ knowledge, there are two characters named Fi, and ‘Ordo’ could refer to different people or even a planet. We suspect there's a decent fandom consensus for these names, and will approve as-is unless Legends fans or the nominator indicate a clarification that would be helpful.
There are a number of nominations that could hypothetically be filled by either a canonical character or an original one. If we don't hear back from you, we will approve as-is. If it's approved them as-is, then your creator can either choose an appropriate character from canon or create an original one that otherwise fulfills the tag. Please comment below if you would like these tags changed to be clear (ex: Any Canonical Female Jedi or Original Female Jedi)
We have rejected the following self-cest pairings, due to the fact that they could hypothetically be fulfilled by a fic about masturbation, and this is outside of the spirit of the exchange. Note - if you want to replace this tag by something that clearly can not be fulfilled by a solo-fun-times fic (ex: Hunter/Time Travelling Older Hunter (TBB)) , please comment your preferred tags below.
Nominator, we get it, but Matt the Radar technician is not, technically, a star wars character. This nomination will appear rejected in your noms, but it can be found in Crossovers (Non-Star Wars) as "Matt the Radar Technician(SNL)/Rick the Door Technician (Any)". P.S. - your nom made me laugh, thank you.
You may also see some rejections coming in. These generally happen for one of two reasons - the nomination was in the wrong fandom (ex: including Disney Canon characters in Legends fandom nominations) or the nomination is no longer rare (Congrats and I'm Sorry). If you have any questions about rejections/nominations in general, feel free to reach out to the mods on discord, via email, or comment below, anon is on.
We've reviewed somewhere around 400-500 tags today, but there's still some more to go! We may need to issue a further clarifications post, but once the tags are all reviewed and the tagset is cleaned up, sign ups will open!
We are well on our way through nominations cleanups, and we've discovered some tags that could use clarification. Please read the following and respond if you see your tag (Anon is on for comments). You are also welcome to respond if it is not your tag, but you think you have input that may help the mods in figuring it out - please clarify that you are not the nominator in that case.
Clarifications
Ordo and Fi
To the mods’ knowledge, there are two characters named Fi, and ‘Ordo’ could refer to different people or even a planet. We suspect there's a decent fandom consensus for these names, and will approve as-is unless Legends fans or the nominator indicate a clarification that would be helpful.
- Fi/Ordo (Legends)
- Fi/Ordo/Maze (Legends)
- Fi/Sev (Legends)
- Fi/Sev/Scorch (Legends)
- Ordo/Maze/Arligan Zey (Legends)
- Ordo/Maze (Legends)
Vague Tags - Canon vs Original
There are a number of nominations that could hypothetically be filled by either a canonical character or an original one. If we don't hear back from you, we will approve as-is. If it's approved them as-is, then your creator can either choose an appropriate character from canon or create an original one that otherwise fulfills the tag. Please comment below if you would like these tags changed to be clear (ex: Any Canonical Female Jedi or Original Female Jedi)
- Bo-Katan Kryze (Disney)/Any Female Jedi (TCW)
- Leia Organa (OT)/Any Female Jedi (TCW)
- Original Female Republic Navy Member/Any Female Jedi (TCW)
- Arla Fett/Any Female Jedi (Any)
- Jedi Master of Choice/Jedi Padawan of Choice (Any)
- Mand'alor of Choice/Mandalorian of Choice (Any)
- Sith Lord of Choice/Sith Apprentice of Choice (Any)
- Any Male New Republic Senator (Any)/Luke Skywalker (Mando)
- Original Female Republic Navy Member/Any Female Jedi (TCW)
- Bil Valen| Sixth Brother/Unidentified Black Sun Agent (Any) (Note - for this one we would suggest Bil Valen| Sixth Brother (Any)/ Canonical Unidentified Black Sun Agent (Ahsoka) if you want the specific Black Sun Agent that appears in the Ahsoka show)
- Rakatan Predor of Choice/Force Hound(s) of Choice
Selfcest
We have rejected the following self-cest pairings, due to the fact that they could hypothetically be fulfilled by a fic about masturbation, and this is outside of the spirit of the exchange. Note - if you want to replace this tag by something that clearly can not be fulfilled by a solo-fun-times fic (ex: Hunter/Time Travelling Older Hunter (TBB)) , please comment your preferred tags below.
- Hunter/Hunter
- Crosshair/Crosshair
Matt the Radar Technician is not Star Wars
Nominator, we get it, but Matt the Radar technician is not, technically, a star wars character. This nomination will appear rejected in your noms, but it can be found in Crossovers (Non-Star Wars) as "Matt the Radar Technician(SNL)/Rick the Door Technician (Any)". P.S. - your nom made me laugh, thank you.
General Information
You may also see some rejections coming in. These generally happen for one of two reasons - the nomination was in the wrong fandom (ex: including Disney Canon characters in Legends fandom nominations) or the nomination is no longer rare (Congrats and I'm Sorry). If you have any questions about rejections/nominations in general, feel free to reach out to the mods on discord, via email, or comment below, anon is on.
What's next?
We've reviewed somewhere around 400-500 tags today, but there's still some more to go! We may need to issue a further clarifications post, but once the tags are all reviewed and the tagset is cleaned up, sign ups will open!
due South: Sunday Dinner by ArtConundrum (SpaceTimeConundrum)
Sep. 23rd, 2025 01:44 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Fandom: due South
Characters/Pairings: Benton Fraser, Ray Vecchio, Diefenbaker, Francesca Vecchio, Ma Vecchio, Vecchio family
Rating: Gen
Length: three-panel comic
Content Notes: no AO3 warnings apply
Creator Links: ArtConundrum (SpaceTimeConundrum) on AO3
Themes: Food and cooking, Family, Domestic
Summary: Dinner at the Vecchio house is always an adventure.
Reccer's Notes: An excellent set of panels with Dief and Ma Vecchio cooking, Fraser feeding the smallest Vecchio, and all of them at the dinner table. It's cheerfully domestic and perfectly captures the warm chaos of a Vecchio family dinner.
Fanwork Links: Sunday Dinner
Characters/Pairings: Benton Fraser, Ray Vecchio, Diefenbaker, Francesca Vecchio, Ma Vecchio, Vecchio family
Rating: Gen
Length: three-panel comic
Content Notes: no AO3 warnings apply
Creator Links: ArtConundrum (SpaceTimeConundrum) on AO3
Themes: Food and cooking, Family, Domestic
Summary: Dinner at the Vecchio house is always an adventure.
Reccer's Notes: An excellent set of panels with Dief and Ma Vecchio cooking, Fraser feeding the smallest Vecchio, and all of them at the dinner table. It's cheerfully domestic and perfectly captures the warm chaos of a Vecchio family dinner.
Fanwork Links: Sunday Dinner
SGA: A Place On The Corner by Cesare, anatsuno
Sep. 23rd, 2025 12:43 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Fandom: Stargate Atlantis
Characters/Pairings: John Sheppard/Rodney McKay, Ronon Dex, Teyla Emmagan, Radek Zelenka, Elizabeth, Carson, and other Stargate characters
Rating: General (later works in the series are explicit)
Length: 8467
Content Notes: no AO3 warnings apply
Creator Links: Cesare on AO3, anatsuno on AO3, rhea314 on AO3, rhea314 on Audiofic Archive
Themes: Food and cooking, Friendship, Friends to Lovers, Series, Comfortfic, Complete AU
Summary: Grounded by an injury, John Sheppard leaves the Air Force and, at loose ends, takes up running the bakery he inherited from his mother's family in Colorado Springs.
Reccer's Notes:
This is the first story in a long series called Foster's Bakery. It's a "coffee shop" AU in which John's a baker, and Rodney is of course drawn in by the coffee he serves and becomes a friend, and then a lot more. The relationship is established in this initial fic, and is deepened in later stories in the series. It's a charming story, with the usual Stargate characters as regulars at the bakery - Radek even does a bit of matchmaking. The whole series is very much recommended.
Fanwork Links: A Place On The Corner, and the podfic read by
rhea314 is here
Characters/Pairings: John Sheppard/Rodney McKay, Ronon Dex, Teyla Emmagan, Radek Zelenka, Elizabeth, Carson, and other Stargate characters
Rating: General (later works in the series are explicit)
Length: 8467
Content Notes: no AO3 warnings apply
Creator Links: Cesare on AO3, anatsuno on AO3, rhea314 on AO3, rhea314 on Audiofic Archive
Themes: Food and cooking, Friendship, Friends to Lovers, Series, Comfortfic, Complete AU
Summary: Grounded by an injury, John Sheppard leaves the Air Force and, at loose ends, takes up running the bakery he inherited from his mother's family in Colorado Springs.
Reccer's Notes:
This is the first story in a long series called Foster's Bakery. It's a "coffee shop" AU in which John's a baker, and Rodney is of course drawn in by the coffee he serves and becomes a friend, and then a lot more. The relationship is established in this initial fic, and is deepened in later stories in the series. It's a charming story, with the usual Stargate characters as regulars at the bakery - Radek even does a bit of matchmaking. The whole series is very much recommended.
Fanwork Links: A Place On The Corner, and the podfic read by
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Nominations are Closed, Next Steps, and an FAQ
Sep. 21st, 2025 09:40 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Hello Everyone!
Nominations are now closed, however, don't panic if your noms haven't been approved! We've still got a lot of tagset to review, and probably at least one clarifications post to put up. Watch this space!
The mods need to finish reviewing and finalizing the tagset. As we do that, we will post any lingering clarification questions, likely tomorrow.
Your noms may have been rejected if you nominated a group of characters, if you nominated a pairing that was not rare, or if you nominated in the wrong fandom. If you are disappointed an otherwise eligible ship did not make it in, please see the next question!
Comment here and we'll try to add it in for you, if it's not too late in the sign-up process. We do request you comment with a specific format, which is:
Fandom,Relationship
[ex: Star Wars Crossovers,Ahsoka Tano (Rebels)/Leia Organa (Any)]
If you have more than one relationship in the same fandom, you can add it after the first one, separated by a comma:
Fandom,Relationship,Relationship
[ex: Star Wars Crossovers,Ahsoka Tano (Rebels)/Leia Organa (Any),The Armorer (Mando)/Mon Mothma (Any)]
If you catch something, please comment here, or go to our Discord server and drop a comment in the #tagset-cleanup channel.
The schedule has them opening on Wednesday, 11:59 EST. We're going to work to get the tagset cleaned up, and if we're able to do that ahead of schedule, we may even open ahead of schedule! Be on the lookout for information here.
Any other questions, feel free to drop them in the comments below. Anon is on and comments are screened. See you soon for signups!
Nominations are now closed, however, don't panic if your noms haven't been approved! We've still got a lot of tagset to review, and probably at least one clarifications post to put up. Watch this space!
Next Steps
The mods need to finish reviewing and finalizing the tagset. As we do that, we will post any lingering clarification questions, likely tomorrow.
FAQ
Where did my noms go/why were my noms rejected?
Your noms may have been rejected if you nominated a group of characters, if you nominated a pairing that was not rare, or if you nominated in the wrong fandom. If you are disappointed an otherwise eligible ship did not make it in, please see the next question!
Oh no! I forgot a very important tag! What do I do?
Comment here and we'll try to add it in for you, if it's not too late in the sign-up process. We do request you comment with a specific format, which is:
Fandom,Relationship
[ex: Star Wars Crossovers,Ahsoka Tano (Rebels)/Leia Organa (Any)]
If you have more than one relationship in the same fandom, you can add it after the first one, separated by a comma:
Fandom,Relationship,Relationship
[ex: Star Wars Crossovers,Ahsoka Tano (Rebels)/Leia Organa (Any),The Armorer (Mando)/Mon Mothma (Any)]
What if there's something wrong with a tag in the tagset?
If you catch something, please comment here, or go to our Discord server and drop a comment in the #tagset-cleanup channel.
I'm so excited for signups, when do they open?
The schedule has them opening on Wednesday, 11:59 EST. We're going to work to get the tagset cleaned up, and if we're able to do that ahead of schedule, we may even open ahead of schedule! Be on the lookout for information here.
Any other questions, feel free to drop them in the comments below. Anon is on and comments are screened. See you soon for signups!
Creators Revealed
Sep. 21st, 2025 08:00 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Creators for Just Married 2025 have been revealed! Many thanks to all of this year's participants, with special thanks again to our wonderful pinch hitters. We couldn't have done it without you!
If you have feedback for the exchange, you can e-mail marriageex@gmail.com or comment on this post.
Hope to see you again at next year's weddings!
If you have feedback for the exchange, you can e-mail marriageex@gmail.com or comment on this post.
Hope to see you again at next year's weddings!
Round 154 Has Ended!
Sep. 21st, 2025 07:01 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
We made it! I'm typing this on my phone so excuse any nonsense, or better yet add your own nonsense in the comments! While you're there, be sure to brag about whatever you accomplished this Round! And of course, massive thanks to our Mod Squad:
xandromeodovna, WerebunniesBane
thedarlingone, Rainbow Fairy Godpenguin
lilly_c, Clumsy Rhino
glinda, Supreme Tea Temptress
and of course, our beloved Void, this Round's Champion Usurper
![[profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
and of course, our beloved Void, this Round's Champion Usurper
Assignments out! Initial Pinch Hits here!
Sep. 20th, 2025 01:41 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Assignments have been assigned! Find yours at the email address associated with your AO3 account. Alternatively, you can find it under the "Assignments" tab on the sidebar of your AO3 profile.
If you linked an unfinished letter, please try to complete and/or unlock it as soon as possible.
If your recip's letter is incomplete or locked, please wait to contact me about it until after Sept 27. (Or just work from the signup details.)
Assignments are due October 24, 23:59 UTC. Please note that there will be no extensions.
Initial Pinch Hits
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
These are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 23:59 UTC.
PH #1 (all_ashes):
A Song of Ice and Fire - George R. R. Martin, Don Giovanni - Mozart/Da Ponte, House of the Dragon (TV), The Decameron (TV)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/all_ashes
PH #5 (facethestrange):
镇魂 | Guardian (TV 2018) RPF, 镇魂 | Guardian (TV 2018), 镇魂 | Guardian - priest, Crossover Fandom
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/facethestrange
PH #6 (firsttraintovictoriaville):
Roots of Pacha (Video Game), The White Stripes, Pathfinder: Kingmaker (Video Game), Welcome to the Hyunam-dong Bookshop - Hwang Bo-reum
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/firsttraintovictoriaville
PH #10 (MxKit):
Happy Halloween Scooby-Doo! (2020), The Nameless Game (Gameverse), The Spectacular Spider-Man (Cartoon)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/MxKit
PH #13 (plicate):
Head On (1998), Set It Off (1996), Succession (TV 2018)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/plicate
PH #14 (psychomachia):
Blood Son - Richard Matheson, The Devil You Say - Charles Beaumont, Blood Creek (2009), The Lawnmower Man (1992), The Fall of the House of Usher (TV 2023), The Sinner (TV)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/psychomachia
PH #15 (redgear):
Hallo itt Mátyás király! - Bogáti Péter, 15th Century CE RPF, Debrief (Paracelsus Games Roleplaying Game), Felvidek (Video Game), Dark Prince: The True Story of Dracula (2000)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/redgear
PH #16 (rubylily):
Code Vein (Video Game), 神さまのいない日曜日 | Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi | Sunday Without God (Anime & Manga), Märchen Forest: Mylne and the Forest Gift (Video Game), Octopath Traveler (Video Game), Octopath Traveler II (Video Game), 刀使ノ巫女 | Toji no Miko | Katana Maidens (Anime), void tRrLM(); //Void Terrarium (Video Game), Xenoblade Chronicles 3 (Video Game)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/rubylily
PH #18 (UnhinderedDreams):
Crossover Fandom, The Black Dagger Brotherhood (TV), Buffyverse (TV), I Kissed A Vampire (2010), Nocturnal Animals (2016), The Vampire Diaries (TV)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/UnhinderedDreams
PH #21 (ambiguously):
Star Wars: Obi-Wan Kenobi (TV), Star Wars: Rebels, Star Wars: Resistance (Cartoon), Crossover Fandom, Star Wars: Skeleton Crew (TV)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2025/user/ambiguously
To claim PH21, please comment logged-in or email halloweenmod@gmx.com
( claimed! )
If you linked an unfinished letter, please try to complete and/or unlock it as soon as possible.
If your recip's letter is incomplete or locked, please wait to contact me about it until after Sept 27. (Or just work from the signup details.)
Assignments are due October 24, 23:59 UTC. Please note that there will be no extensions.
Initial Pinch Hits
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
These are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 23:59 UTC.
PH #1 (all_ashes):
PH #5 (facethestrange):
PH #6 (firsttraintovictoriaville):
PH #10 (MxKit):
PH #13 (plicate):
PH #14 (psychomachia):
PH #15 (redgear):
PH #16 (rubylily):
PH #18 (UnhinderedDreams):
PH #21 (ambiguously):
( claimed! )
Mid-Nominations Notes
Sep. 20th, 2025 11:40 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Thanks for all your nominations so far! 2732 fandom choices have been submitted so far (note that if two people nominate the same fandom, that counts twice towards that total).
Nominations will close at 9pm UTC 26 September. If your fandom requires evidence, please also submit it by that time. We can't give a decision on all fandoms on the Evidence Post by close of nominations, but the sooner you make your case, the better your chances of a swift answer.
We've seen some very large fandoms among the nominations! Yuletide is an exchange for rare fandoms. We will reject all of the fandoms below, so if one of them is your nomination, please choose again:
We also won't approve "All Media Types" or "& Related Fandoms". If you've nominated any of the following fandoms, please either pick a specific piece of media, or argue your case on the evidence post.
We've seen nominations for relationships, original characters, or Reader characters. Please only use the Character field to nominate specific characters who appear in a canon. For exceptions, see the eligibility post.
We've also seen many well-formatted nominations and nominations we are excited about! Please keep them coming.
We are happy to answer questions about nominations.
Schedule, Rules, & Collection [still being tweaked for this year] | Contact Mods | Tag Set | Community DW | Community LJ | Discord | Pinch hits on Dreamwidth
Please either sign in to comment, or include a name with your anonymous comments, including replies to others' comments. Unsigned comments will stay screened.
Nominations will close at 9pm UTC 26 September. If your fandom requires evidence, please also submit it by that time. We can't give a decision on all fandoms on the Evidence Post by close of nominations, but the sooner you make your case, the better your chances of a swift answer.
We've seen some very large fandoms among the nominations! Yuletide is an exchange for rare fandoms. We will reject all of the fandoms below, so if one of them is your nomination, please choose again:
- Baldur's Gate (Video Games) - I & II will be approved, as per evidence, but this label will be rejected
- Actor RPF
- Andor (TV)
- Baldur's Gate (Video Games)
- Black Sails (TV)
- 僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga)
- Deltarune (Video Game)
- Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency (TV 2016)
- Downton Abbey
- Gravity Falls
- Horizon (Video Games)
- House M.D.
- 전지적 독자 시점 - 싱숑 | Omniscient Reader - Sing-Shong
- The Pitt (TV)
- プロジェクトセカイ カラフルステージ!| Project SEKAI COLORFUL STAGE! (Video Game)
- 斉木楠雄のΨ難 | Saiki Kusuo no Sai-nan | The Disastrous Life of Saiki K
- Star Trek: Enterprise
- Undertale (Video Game)
- Warframe
We also won't approve "All Media Types" or "& Related Fandoms". If you've nominated any of the following fandoms, please either pick a specific piece of media, or argue your case on the evidence post.
- Ender's Game - All Media Types
- History Boys - All Media Types
- Midsomer Murders - All Media Types
We've seen nominations for relationships, original characters, or Reader characters. Please only use the Character field to nominate specific characters who appear in a canon. For exceptions, see the eligibility post.
We've also seen many well-formatted nominations and nominations we are excited about! Please keep them coming.
We are happy to answer questions about nominations.
Please either sign in to comment, or include a name with your anonymous comments, including replies to others' comments. Unsigned comments will stay screened.